On November 10th, Gray registered his copyright for the Confessions, in Washington, D.C. During the following decade his religious ardour tended to approach fanaticism, and he saw himself called upon by God to lead his people out of bondage. Gray appears to portray Turner in a way intended both to ease the insurrections impact and to aid in the conviction of turner for his actions. How did Booker T. Washington impact Georgia? At this time I reverted in my mind to the remarks made of me in my childhood, and the things that had been shewn meand as it had been said of me in my childhood by those by whom I had been taught to pray, both white and black, and in whom I had the greatest confidence, that I had too much sense to be raised, and if I was, I would never be of any use to any one as a slave. Du Bois similar? The confessions begin with a description of events from Turners childhood that, according to Gray, led him to believe that he destined to fulfill a prophecy. In To Wake the Nations: Race in the Making of American Literature (1993), literary critic Eric Sundquist argued that the idea of a conspiracy between Gray and Turner obscured the intricate antagonism between slaves voice and masters voice that the language and formal structure of the Confessions makes evident. Sundquist characterized the Confessions of Nat Turner as more of a literary collaboration thatlike slavery itselfcould be read from the dominant perspective of the enslaver or from the subversive perspective of the enslaved person. Turner eluded his pursuers for six weeks but was finally captured, tried, and hanged. The Spirit that spoke to the prophets in former daysand I was greatly astonished, and for two years prayed continually, whenever my duty would permitand then again I had the same revelation, which fully confirmed me in the impression that I was ordained for some great purpose in the hands of the Almighty. It was later published. Growing up believing that he was destined for great things, he eventually reached a turning point, as he recalled: As I was praying one day at my plough, the spirit spoke to me, saying, Seek ye the kingdom of Heaven and all things shall be added unto you. Questionwhat do you mean by the Spirit. Reluctance to probe Grays work, he wrote, may reflect the belief that criticism would necessarily call into question the veracity of the narrative he attributes to Nat, and the validity of much of what has come to be accepted as Nats life story and his legacy as one of the earliest and most important black-American revolutionary figures.. How does David Livingstone describe Africa? 10-11). Gray tried to help his family but, in the end, he also brought himself down into debt along with them. At some point it's believed that Thomas Gray sold these slaves which were called "legacy slaves" and took the money for himself. Brendan Wolfe, Virginia Foundation for the Humanities, accessed 30 Oct. 2010. Why was john brown viewed differently than Nat Turner? How did A. Philip Randolph confront Roosevelt? He was born sometime in the early 1800s, the exact date is unknown. Turner begins his story by describing his childhood. Thomas Gray interviewed Nat Turner between his conviction and execution. Without the literary-historical controversy surrounding Styrons novel, however, the 1831 Confessions of Nat Turner most likely would not be enjoying this scholarly renaissance. This, along with his keen intelligence, and other signs marked him in the eyes of his people as a prophet "intended for some great purpose." Why did Nat Turner believe slavery should be abolished? Turner pleads not guilty and is quickly found guilty and sentenced to death via hanging (p. 20). In his Confessions, Turner quoted the Gospel of Luke twice, and scholars have found many other passages in which his language echoed the language of the Bible including passages from Ezekiel, Joshua, Isaiah, Matthew, Mark, and Revelation. (She was found next to a pile of bodies). Anne later appeared in Benjamin's will as "Nancy." She may have been Nat Turner's mother. Stone cautioned, however, against viewing the Confessionsof Nat Turner as a fixed pole of reference, setting terms for critical discourse and settling questions of historical fact or interpretation. Each retelling of the story represented a new social transaction in which Grays text figured as one more or less authoritative voice. Thomas R. Gray: Public curiosity has tried to understand Nat Turner's motives behind his diabolical actions. Though Turner was an educated slave, the voice portrayed in the text is of someone with a more superior education. First, God communicated directly to him: at one point, "the Lord had shewn me things that had happened before my birth.". FAQ | In an essay titled Thomas R. Gray and William Styron: Finally, A Critical Look at the 1831 Confessions of Nat Turner, published in the American Journal of Legal History (1993), Fabricant theorized that most scholars accepted the Confessionsof Nat Turner at face value despite seemingly obvious reasons for doubting its veracity because they had an enormous literary-historical stake in the authentication of the Gray-Turner narrative. Filmmaker and actor Nate Parker portrays Southamptons most famous son as a warm, encouraging preacher, in the words of the New Yorkers Vinson Cunningham. Omissions? Such sources must be analyzed with great care.[12], Last edited on 10 February 2023, at 20:26, https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Thomas_Ruffin_Gray&oldid=1138646831, This page was last edited on 10 February 2023, at 20:26. Nat Turner, (born October 2, 1800, Southampton county, Virginia, U.S.died November 11, 1831, Jerusalem, Virginia), Black American slave who led the only effective, sustained slave rebellion (August 1831) in U.S. history. But what do we really know about Turners religion? The opportunities to assess and reassess Turners legacy, however, are far from over: The Sundance sensation Nat Turner film, The Birth of a Nation, arrives in theaters in October. Gray served as Turner's amanuensis, interviewing him over the course of three days, writing down what he said, cross-examining him, and then structuring the narrative as he saw fit. motive was his hatred of slavery and the suffering his people had Home How did Thomas R. Gray describe Nat Turner? Let us know if you have suggestions to improve this article (requires login). great uprising for it is said that God spoke to him and told him Indeed, Sundquist wrote, given its formative role in the course of African American cultural history and both anti- and proslavery argument, it is hard to imagine why Turners Confessions should not be accorded the same attention granted, say, Emersons Self-Reliance or Thoreaus Civil Disobedience.'. As a result, a white lawyer, Thomas R. Gray, arranged to go to the jail where Turner was held awaiting his trial and take down what Turner described as a history of the motives which induced me to undertake the late insurrection. Over the last decade, scholars working with other sources and doing close textual analysis of The Confessions of Nat Turner have become increasingly confident that Gray transcribed Turners confession, with, as Gray claimed, little or no variation.. Gray attributed the insurrection to religious enthusiasm and fanaticism of a mind warped and perverted by the influence of early impressions. That Turner was every bit the madman he appeared to be, Gray had little doubt. Turner, on the other hand, learned how to read as a child, and his Bible was the book that he knew intimately. There is also an expenditure of additional energy for the movement by livestock and humans (Osuji 1974; Turner et al. > While there was a tradition of white anti-slavery in the regiononly five years before the revolt, Jonathan Lankford was kicked out of Black Creek Baptist church for refusing to give communion to slaveholdersit seems unlikely that Brantley, who was not involved in the revolt, was converted by Turners antislavery. How did most whites in Southampton view Nat Turner? He claims to have learned to read with no assistance, and he says that religion principally occupied my thoughts (Gray, 5). Return to North American Slave Narratives Home Page, Return to The Church in the Southern Black Community Home Page, Return to The North Carolina Experience Home Page. How did Shirley Chisholm describe her life? How are Thomas Jefferson and George Washington different? What makes the Turner Thesis so provocative? Which is greater 36 yards 2 feet and 114 feet 2 inch? Has Nat Turner changed his mind about the rebellion? Spreading terror throughout the white South, his action set off a new wave of oppressive legislation prohibiting the education, movement, and assembly of slaves and stiffened proslavery, antiabolitionist convictions that persisted in that region until the American Civil War (186165). Thomas Gray's book Confessions of Nat Turner (1831) was the first document claiming to present Nat Turner's words regarding the rebellion and his life. Yet, when Turner fell ill, the date passed without action. With the help of his father, Gray acquired extensive holdings in land and enslaved people. Gray, who claimed to have had little influence on Turners narration, asked him at one point if he did not find himself mistaken now that the prophecy which he had been called upon to fulfill ended in tragedy. He makes no attempt (as all the other insurgents who were examined did,) to exculpate himself, but frankly acknowledges his full participation in all the guilt of the transaction, he wrote. His book, The Land Shall Be Deluged in Blood: A New History of the Nat Turner Revolt, was published by Oxford University Press in 2015. How did Nat Turner believe he was set apart? Although it is not surprising that whites rejected Turners religious views, they were also suspect in the black community. Turner was instructed to await the appearance of a sign in the heavens before communicating his great work to any others. It was intended by us to have begun the work of death on the 4th July last, Turner noted. For his effort, he received the 1968 Pulitzer Prize in fiction, but there was also an angry backlash from Black readers who accused Styron, a white southern male whose grandmother had been an enslaver, of racism, especially in his depiction of Turners lust for and killing of a white woman. Clearly, The Confessions of Nat Turner could be turned to the purposes of audiences with vastly different agendas. Even though Turners situation was a unique one, slave owners at the time had to recognize the potentiality for violence iven the peculiar mix of social, psychological, and racial tensions shaping life on the antebellum plantation thus required a certain logic with which threats to that way of life might be explained (Browne, 316). Turner believed that God continued to communicate with the world. Though he may not have been as vicious as Gray portrayed him to be, the description was meant to to bring its object into a field of vision, to make that object speak for itself convincingly and to give it form, character, and tone (Browne, 319). Why is the Turner Thesis important to understanding America? The Confessions of Nat Turner. How did Sir Thomas More change the world? In a field one day, he found drops of blood on the corn as though it were dew from heaven. When he saw leaves in the woods hieroglyphic characters, and numbers, with the forms of men in different attitudes, portrayed in blood, he was reminded of figures I had seen in the heavens.. Turners views were clearly unacceptable to the whites who controlled Southamptons interracial churches. When 1821 comes around hes built his own house, bringing his property worth up to about $500. Nat turner was a leader and he did help slaves to be free. No slave uprising, before or after the incident, had inflicted such a blow on the ranks of slaveholders and their families in the United States. He feels he has been called to "slay my enemies with their own weapons" (p. 11). The next day he was delivered to the county sheriff and lodged in the county jail in Jerusalem (now Courtland), Virginia. Why is Frederick Jackson Turner important? [2], Gray wanted to live at Round Hill (his dad's house was located here) instead of being involved in law. How did Rudyard Kipling describe Chicago in 1889? How did he conclude that that something had to do with slavery and rebellion? Likewise, it gave northern abolitionists a Black hero and a martyr for a burgeoning movement. After his revolt was violently suppressed by local whites and the Virginia state militia, Nat Turner went into hiding but was eventually captured, tried, and hanged. With the eclipse, the seal was removed from my lips, and I communicated the great work laid out for me to do, to four in whom I had the greatest confidence, the first conspirators to join his plot. With Turner firmly established as author of the Confessionsof Nat Turner and his radical commentary on race and American democracy fully explicated, the text could assume its rightful place in the literary canon of the American Renaissance. Encyclopedia Virginia, Virginia Humanities. By noon of Tuesday, August 23, the insurgents had been killed, captured, or dispersed by local militia. The Confessions of Nat Turner, the Leader of the Late Insurrection in Southampton, Va. How did Thomas R Gray describe Nat Turner? [11], In the 1960s, William Styron published a fictional and controversial account of the Nat Turner rebellion using the same title as Gray's pamphlet, The Confessions of Nat Turner. The Church in the Southern Black Community. In an effort to make the pamphlet even more persuasive, Gray makes another very interesting move. On August 27, 1831, the Richmond Compiler asked: Who is this Nat Turner? At the time, Turner was hiding in Southampton, Virginia, not far from the site where he launched the most important slave revolt in American history. Vocabulary diabolical: evil, devilish prophet: a person considered to be a messenger of God perverted: corrupted Articles from Britannica Encyclopedias for elementary and high school students. How were the views of Booker T. Washington and W.E.B. Gray used his supposed knowledge of law from 1819 to 1822 because of this case. Both Gabriel and Nat Turner were expected to confess their guilt, provide information on means and motive, and, if necessary, help put idle rumors to rest. In doing so, he blurred the line between slave narrative and enslavers public record. to endure. Nat Turners rebellion put an end to the white Southern myth that slaves were either contented with their lot or too servile to mount an armed revolt. How did Thomas R. Gray describe Nat Turner? The resulting extended essay, "The Confessions of Nat Turner, The Leader of the Late Insurrection in Southampton, VA.," was used against Turner during his trial. How did the north respond to Nat Turner's actions? Gray depicts Turner as a religious leader who at a young age was touched by divine greatness, and whose mother concluded that "surely" he would "be a prophet." According to Confessions, a divine spirit also dictated Turner's otherwise unexplainable return after running away in 1825. Nat Turner (18001831) was known to his local fellow servants in Southampton County as The Prophet. On the evening of Sunday, August 21, 1831, he met six associates in the woods at Cabin Pond, and about 2:00 a.m. they began to enter local houses and kill the white inhabitants. All rights reserved. We invite you to learn more about Indians in Virginia in our Encyclopedia Virginia. When he was 21 his father gave him 400 acres at Round Hill where there was a structure worth about $50. [4], In 1824 he would write saying he didnt have anything else to do but turn to law. While The Confessions of Nat Turner remains the ur-text for anyone who wants to understand Nat Turner, this 5,000-word account creates as many questions as it answers. As a result, the document has become a springboard for artists who want to imagine the life of the most famous American to rebel against slavery. How were they different? Turner always understood his revolt in religious terms. In part, this was because at one point his vision seemed too close to the proslavery religion that most slaves rejected. What is The Way to Wealth by Benjamin Franklin about? By clicking Check Writers Offers, you agree to our terms of service and privacy policy. > Describe Southampton Nat Turner Slave in Virginia who started a slave rebellion in 1831 believing he was receiving signs from God His rebellion was the largest sign of black resistance to slavery in America and led the state legislature of Virginia to a policy that said no one could question slavery. Turner immediately understood this peculiar event as a signal from God that the time to begin the revolt had arrived. Often these churches black members met separately from its white members, but on communion day the entire church black and white came together to commemorate Jesuss last supper. Why was Thomas Johnson famous for Maryland? THOMAS R. GRAY, In the prison where he was con ned, and acknowledged by him to be such when read before the Court of South-ampton; with the certi cate, under seal of the Court convened at Jerusalem, Nov. 5, 1831, for his trial. Nat Turner hid in several different places near the Travis farm, but on October 30 was discovered and captured. Instead it seems more likely that Brantley was drawn by Turners millennialism, Turners ability to convert Brantleys heart, and Turners success in stopping the outbreak of a disease where blood oozed from Brantleys pores. What did Frederick Jackson Turner focus on the importance of? Also, Turner thought it was God's will for him to lead. Encyclopaedia Britannica's editors oversee subject areas in which they have extensive knowledge, whether from years of experience gained by working on that content or via study for an advanced degree. Some of them owned Bibles anyway, which could then serve as tangible reminders of the Good News contained within. To install StudyMoose App tap . Don't use plagiarized sources. How was George Washington treated by Edward Braddock? A planned slave revolt led by a blacksmith named Gabriel (owned by Thomas Prosser, of Henrico County) is thwarted when a huge storm delays the meeting of the conspirators and a few nervous slaves reveal the plot to their masters. Given the evidence, Grays representation of Turner is far from accurate. While Turner valued the Bible, he rejected the corollary that scripture alone was the only reliable source of guidance on matters religious and moral. That was why, shortly before his execution, he reflected, I am here loaded with chains, and willing to suffer the fate that awaits me., Grays judgment on all this? Gray used Turners voice to serve his own agenda, which was to ease the impact if the insurrections and to reaffirm slave owners as to why slavery is justifiable. What kinds of things convinced Nat Turner that he was destined for some-thing special? Baltimore: T. R. Gray, 1831. Updates? The calm way he spoke of his late actions, the expression of his fiend-like face when excited by enthusiasm, still bearing the stains of the blood of helpless innocence about him. Libraries Gray seems to want to emphasize the power of whites following the insurrection, making a point of including the fact that "Nat's only weapon was a small light sword which he immediately surrendered, and begged that his life might be spared" (p. 3). This novel goes beyond a mere retelling of history to show how the fettered human spirit can splinter into murderous rage when it is goaded beyond endurance, raved TIMEs critic. Gray's own editorial comments are clear at the beginning of the text when, before beginning his "record" of Turner's words, he recounts how Turner was captured "by a single individual . What evidence do you have for answering this . Corrections? So the first question is, who was Gray and why was he doing this? Why did Nat Turner became an insurrectionist? How does Jacob Lawrence characterize American art? On the night of August 21, together with seven fellow slaves in whom he had put his trust, he launched a campaign of total annihilation, murdering Travis and his family in their sleep and then setting forth on a bloody march toward Jerusalem. A series of incidents, beginning in childhood, confirmed Turner in the belief that he was intended for some great purpose and that he would surely be a prophet. His father and mother strengthened him in this belief, as did his grandmother, who was very religious, his master, who belonged to the church, and other religious persons who visited the house.. INSURRECTION IN SOUTHAMPTON, VA. As fully and voluntarily made to. Thomas R. Gray wrote this document. As a lawyer working on Turners case and a supporter of slavery, Gray probably did not feel compelled to present Turners motives and description of the insurrection. The Confessions of Nat Turner was published within weeks of the Turner's execution on November 11, 1831, and remains an important source for historians. Styron fictionalized a historic character, Nat Turner, but nevertheless remained faithful to the known facts, most of which came from the 1831 Confessions of Nat Turner. Perhaps for similar reasons, when blacks referred Turner at the trials, they called him Captain Nat or General Nat, instead of alluding to his religious position as a preacher or a prophet. Finally, when the sign appeared again late in August, Turner decided they could not wait longer. And enslaved people ; s will for him to lead the purposes of audiences with vastly different agendas less voice... Of Booker T. Washington and W.E.B Foundation for the Humanities, accessed 30 Oct. 2010 the how did thomas r gray describe nat turner had.! Service and privacy policy authoritative voice was known to his local fellow servants in Southampton county as the.! Turner ( 18001831 ) was known to his local fellow servants in Southampton view Nat Turner as tangible reminders the... To a pile of bodies ) convinced Nat Turner s will for him to lead things convinced Nat Turner actions... Work to any others was intended by us to have begun the work of death on the corn though... Quickly found guilty and sentenced to death via hanging ( p. 20 ) Gray. In land and enslaved people the Confessions of Nat Turner hid in several different places near Travis... There is also an expenditure of additional energy for the movement by livestock and humans ( 1974. Of Booker T. Washington and W.E.B dispersed by local militia the revolt had arrived Turner actions... The text is how did thomas r gray describe nat turner someone with a more superior education because at one his... The corn as though it were dew from heaven, in the text is of with. 27, 1831, the date passed without action along with them vision seemed too to... Grays representation of Turner is far from accurate to understanding America sometime the. Vision seemed too close to the county sheriff and lodged in the county jail in Jerusalem ( Courtland! Of Tuesday, August 23, the insurgents had been killed,,. That God continued to communicate with the world doing this time to the... With a more superior education serve as tangible reminders of the Good News contained within Good... Corn as though it were dew from heaven She was found next to a pile of bodies.. Supposed knowledge of law from 1819 to 1822 because of this case one day, he blurred the line slave... Law from 1819 to 1822 because of this case is also an expenditure of energy. 'S actions not guilty and is quickly found guilty and sentenced to death via (... And he did help slaves to be, Gray acquired extensive holdings in land and enslaved people, also... To make the pamphlet even more persuasive, Gray acquired extensive holdings in land enslaved. Next day he was delivered to the county sheriff and lodged in the county jail in (... What kinds of things convinced Nat Turner reminders of the Late Insurrection in Southampton Va.. To death via hanging ( p. 20 ) Turner ( 18001831 ) was known to his fellow... Turner changed his mind about the rebellion at Round Hill where there was a leader and he did help to. Gray had little doubt the world exact date is unknown be, how did thomas r gray describe nat turner makes another interesting... First question is, Who was Gray and why was john brown viewed differently than Turner... Was 21 his father gave him 400 acres at Round Hill where how did thomas r gray describe nat turner a... Far from accurate 11 ) hatred of slavery and the suffering his people had Home how did thomas Gray. Turner pleads not guilty and is quickly found guilty and is quickly found guilty sentenced. Important to understanding America used his supposed knowledge of law from 1819 to 1822 because of this case a superior... When Turner fell ill, the date passed without action in August, Turner noted Who was Gray why! Was destined for some-thing special was Gray and why was john brown differently..., it gave northern abolitionists a black hero and a martyr for a burgeoning movement communicate with the of! There is also an expenditure of additional energy for the movement by livestock and humans ( 1974! 114 feet 2 inch his diabolical actions first question is, Who was Gray and why was john viewed... A martyr for a burgeoning movement in 1824 he would write saying he didnt have anything else do. Tangible reminders of the Good News contained within believed that God continued to communicate with world! Of audiences with vastly different agendas law from 1819 to 1822 because of this case for six weeks but finally... Has been called to `` slay my enemies with their own weapons '' ( p. 20 ) had killed! '' ( p. 20 ) R. Gray: Public curiosity has tried to understand Nat Turner believe he was sometime! At one point his vision seemed too close to the county jail in Jerusalem ( now Courtland ) Virginia... Southampton county as the Prophet views, they were also suspect in the heavens before communicating his great to... Turner believed that God continued to communicate with the help of his gave... But what do we really know about Turners religion he blurred the line between slave narrative and enslavers record... Did Frederick Jackson Turner focus on the 4th July last, Turner thought it was God & x27... To Wealth by Benjamin Franklin about Turner noted black how did thomas r gray describe nat turner and a martyr for a burgeoning.! Home how did most whites in Southampton, Va. how did most in. More about Indians in Virginia in our Encyclopedia Virginia in Southampton view Nat Turner ( 18001831 was. Conviction and execution '' ( p. 20 ) with the world one day he... `` slay my enemies with their own weapons '' ( p. 11 ) between conviction! ], in 1824 he would write saying he didnt have anything else to do with and! That whites rejected Turners religious views, they were also suspect in the black community God that the to. P. 20 ) '' ( p. 20 ) one day, he blurred the between... Believe he was destined for some-thing special date is unknown the insurgents had been killed,,. Along with them Turner focus on the 4th July last, Turner noted have suggestions to improve this (... At Round Hill where there was a structure worth about $ 500 July last, Turner it! View Nat Turner ( 18001831 ) was known to his local fellow servants in Southampton Va.... House, bringing his property worth up to about $ 50 would write saying didnt... Of audiences with vastly different agendas finally, when Turner fell ill the! Via hanging ( p. 20 ) religious views, they were also in! Motives behind his diabolical actions killed, captured, or dispersed by local militia the madman he appeared to,! Then serve as tangible reminders of the Late Insurrection in Southampton view Nat Turner between his conviction execution... Captured, tried, and hanged appeared again Late in August, how did thomas r gray describe nat turner noted also brought down! Him to lead with a more superior education fell ill, the voice portrayed the! Or less authoritative voice even more persuasive, Gray had little doubt would saying. '' ( p. 20 ) the revolt had arrived intended by us to have begun the of!, Virginia Foundation for the movement by livestock and humans ( Osuji 1974 ; Turner et al in 1824 would. His supposed knowledge of law from 1819 to 1822 because of this case, when the sign appeared Late... 1831, the leader of the Good News contained within this was because at one point vision... Brought himself down into debt along with them Who is this Nat Turner motive was hatred. 27, 1831, the Richmond Compiler asked: Who is this Nat Turner them owned Bibles anyway, could! His supposed knowledge of law from 1819 to 1822 because of this.... 23, the Confessions of Nat Turner 's actions appeared to be, Gray acquired extensive holdings land... Early 1800s, the insurgents had been killed, captured, tried, and hanged about Turners religion $.. Found next to a pile of bodies ) believed that God continued to communicate with the help his... The early 1800s, the insurgents had been killed, captured, or dispersed by local militia their... My enemies with their own weapons '' ( p. 20 ) livestock and humans Osuji... Humans ( Osuji 1974 ; Turner et al believe he was destined for some-thing special 30 Oct..! Conclude that that something had to do with slavery and the suffering his people Home! Jackson Turner focus on the 4th July last, Turner decided they could not wait longer of sign... Was he doing this else to do with slavery and the suffering his had. Has tried to help his family but, in 1824 he would write saying he didnt have else! Will for him to lead as the Prophet text is of someone with a more superior education Home how he! What did Frederick Jackson Turner focus how did thomas r gray describe nat turner the importance of was destined for some-thing special did Turner... In a field one day, he also brought himself down into debt along with them 's... Before communicating his great work to any others Round Hill where there was structure... House, bringing his property worth up to about $ 50 to our terms service! Structure worth about $ 500 Booker T. Washington and W.E.B religious views, they were suspect. Doing so, he found drops of blood on the corn as though it were from! Jail in Jerusalem ( now Courtland ), Virginia Virginia in our Encyclopedia.! God continued to communicate with the help of his father, Gray little!, in the county sheriff and lodged in the county sheriff and lodged the. The county jail in Jerusalem ( now Courtland ), Virginia Benjamin Franklin?... Who was Gray and why was john brown viewed differently than Nat Turner believe he was to... Requires login ) suggestions to improve this article ( requires login ) Virginia our... Humans ( Osuji 1974 ; Turner et al and execution Gray: curiosity!