You can also use it as a substitute for box pudding in cake recipes. I stirred in the amount that looked right, and then omitted the vanilla and added coconut extract until it tasted right. Continue to whisk until the pudding has thickened. Can I use powder d sugar instead of granulated sugar? Ive been wondering how to wean myself off of my dependence on pudding mix. I too make a Barcardi rum cake recipe calls for yellow cake mix and vanilla instant pudding have made it for years. I already make cooked pudding from scratch all the time. Then add your angel food cake squares. happy following you..:) I stupidly told her it was homemade and now she is begging for the recipe. This is so awesome! Also note when you use powdered sugar in cakes, your final product might be a little dense, but should be okay in puddings. I am so glad I ran across your recipes on pinterest and have fallen in love with your webpage. If you want to make and store dry instant pudding mix, use the dry milk powder, and omit the vanilla. Pour in the rest of the milk, the 2 tablespoons of sugar, vanilla and the pudding mix. Instant Pudding Mix means you mix with milk and stir until it starts to thicken, no cooking required. 18 mins for cupcakes, 25 35 for cakes, depending on size of the pan. Since custard is less sweet than pudding, so you may have to add more sugar than usual if you want to get the best results. Would crushing dried bananas in a food processor work? The truth is, that the from-scratch versions of these things take literally minutes to make and are infinitely cheaper, not to mention healthier. Example: Homemade Instant Vanilla Pudding Mix If you don't have any form of white chocolate, you can replace it with milk chocolate; just keep in mind the appearance will be quite different and the flavor slightly off compared to the original recipe. This sounds like a delicious Cooked pudding mix, convenient and definitely cheaper. This should work. I just leave them in the jar until Im done with the mix. I use this in baked recipes calling for boxed instant pudding, exclusively. Thank you! Im continually checking back to your blog for it, but for now Ill settle with the vanilla one! Agreed, truth does matter, but you have clearly missed the point. Do you know of some place that sell that? To make your own chocolate pudding without all the chemicals, combine 1/2 cup of white sugar, 3 tablespoons of cornstarch and 1/3 cup of unsweetened cocoa in a 1- or 2-quart saucepan. Stir the ingredients until they are completely combined. Hello, if I intend to use this in a recipe that calls for instant pudding do I use the whole portion? 1. Vanilla beans??? Any suggestions for how to make candy cane pudding mix? Like 3.5oz of your mix is the same as the box one? When using in baking, is it a 1 for 1 substitution as the boxed instant pudding mixes? Hope that helps! But if they are so similar, why do both exist? It doesnt have to set up for hours in the refrigerator. The purpose of the recipe, if you read closely, is to serve as a substitute for cake/cookie recipes which call for adding a small box of instant pudding in its dry form. I would need to drive four hours to find those. I would check the jar to see if it has a conversion one vanilla bean is equivalent to about 2 teaspoons of vanilla extract. To bake: Preheat the oven to 375F. do stop by mine sometime. Im not sure if that was my error or the amount i used. I had the same problem last week! Thanks. Thanks! Instant always means no cook. One 3.3 oz. I dont understand why people are so confused as you clearly state its a DIY instant pudding MIX and not a DIY instant pudding. I hate when someone posts a recipe, and fails to tell you, how much to use. CREAM MIXTURE. but i measured 3.4oz box mix before and it was way less than one cup. La receta que tan gentilmente has compartido necesita coccin. Remove from stove top, pour into a large bowl and let rest for 5-10 minutes until warm and ready to eat, or place in the fridge and let cool completely. Thanks for the wonderful website and recipes. Youd need instant cleargel for instant pudding mix, so it would thicken without cooking. Add spoonfuls of Cool Whip, folding with each addition until the whole tub is used and there are no lumps. Hi Laura, King Arthur Flour sells powdered milk, but I dont know if they ship to the UK. This site is dedicated to bringing thorough and insightful answers to some of our most common cooking questions. Weve been craving coconut pudding so I just added shaved coconut to the pudding after it had boiled, and cool a little. It works like a charm in place of the Jello instant vanilla pudding mix.I did sub arrowroot 1:1 for the cornstarch since Im very allergic . Jello chocolate pudding contains no artificial sweeteners or high fructose corn syrup. You may have to play with the amount of cornstarch you use in the recipe to find the right combo. I am hoping it can be used in a recipe without cooking it! When I make cooked puddings in the microwave (which I do at least twice a week, I do love my warm pudding! Completely not the point. Unfortunately, I cant get non fat dry milk. Hi Michelle, Bake at 350. The 2 cups of milk, mixed with 1/2 of the pudding mix, will serve how many ? Bake 10 to 12 minutes or until light brown. Another great instant pudding substitute is the pudding mix that requires to be cooked instead. This is super! This is so clever and simple. Awesome to hear you already used it! this article is pretty garbage the texture and the flavor base is completely wrong honestly seems like this person just threw it together 5 minutes and didnt even bother testing it for 1 if they wanted to actually make instant pudding mix they would have to use gelatinized starch and a small amount of ultratex for a smother texture and to completely get rid of the cooking step and for flavoring it is much better to use the whole bean sliced lengthwise and roasted in the oven you will notice when it is done because the aroma changes completely and become very intense then blend the entire bean into powder also the use of instant egg yolk powder is absolutely necessary in order to be able to make a full bodied flavor not to mention they are using basically 1/3 the amount of salt necessary and while vanilla is delicious i often find using just vanilla leaves any custard or pudding tasting hollow so id recommend adding a small amount of artificial vanilla to the sugar the night before and letting it dry over night then blend it the day after and also the Addison of a small amount of cassis and rum extract add a nice complexity. EXCITED! It is perfect. Hi Michelle, Instant white chocolate pudding is fat-free. Thick, creamy, and decadent, this White Chocolate Pudding recipe is made completely from scratch. Its quick to create a vanilla pudding substitute itll take you less than 5 minutes if you have a few key ingredients: Take a mixing bowl and mix all the ingredients together thoroughly. 1 teaspoon salt. We prefer to make things from scratch also, so this will be great! I dont have a white cake mix, but I do have a yellow cake mix! This will produce a cake that is much moister than your typical out-of-the-box cake. Now just wait until you see what I have up my sleeve. its hard to find vanilla beans where i live and if i do findthey would be quite expensive! but i dnt have vanilla beans.can i use the normal vanilla?? Jello Chocolate Pudding Mix is a tasty treat on its own as well as a perfect ingredient for desserts. As in you dont cook it ! This is what I made tonight. Also, certain recipes will explicitly call for INSTANT, not cook and serve, therefore, this is incorrect all around. I have searched and see its a Jell-o dessert which I am unable to get in Western Australia. I knew I wanted to make the cake from scratch, but boy does that box of pudding do wonders to a cake, right? Adding too much could alter the flavor, so be careful. The title is misleading Instant Pudding Mix is a no-cook pudding powder. I am working on a chocolate version as well, so stay tuned! Since there are no eggs, its white. NO pudding anywhere. I was looking for an instant and popped onto this version of a cooked pudding. Blood Orange and White Chocolate Cream Cups Recipe. Add to cart. Recipe is a real lifesaver! Thank you! Hi Regina, I am not familiar with vanilla bean powder (only use extract, paste or whole beans). WE LOVE THAT. 1/2 T of baking sodano edit button. Content on this site is for reference purposes and is not intended to substitute for advice given by a physician, pharmacist, or other licensed health-care professional. ??? My question is, is this really an instant where you can add it to recipes that call for instant pudding. Am going to have to try this as I like making my own stuff too. Can you tell me how much of this recipe for a small box of instant pudding mix? Use 50% power and stir every 30 seconds until the chocolate is melted and smooth. Im trying (in vain so far; *sigh*) to replicate from scratch a boxed-cake + pudding-mix combo that I made for my sister. How to Make a White Box Cake Into Chocolate Cake, 4 Corn Syrup Substitutes for Homemade Icing. Thank you for coming to the rescueAGAIN! As milk is just a component that helps liquify the pudding mix, you can change it with different types of milk with slight changes in the taste. Add the brown sugar and granulated sugar, beat for another 1 - 2 minutes until lighter in color and fluffy. Learn More Oh She Cookswas created by a husband and wife team that has been cooking for their small family for decades. Boxed pudding made in a saucepan on the stovetop is not instant and is never labeled as such. Avocado. This is awesome : ) I have a cake that my mother-in-law makes that Im trying to make from scratch that calls for pudding mix perfect timing. Thanks!! Instant pudding is just the powders (sugar, cornstarch) combined with a dry milk powder instead of fresh milk. Vanilla pudding is my favorite. kakeladi - formerly from Visalia, CA. Use it for dessert as is, or make a pie or a pudding parfait. I am glad to know that it works. I like to date my stuff (Im a little OCD) and was wondering how long before it becomes stale. Hi Tara, I would not omit the dry milk given what youre planning to do with it. Exactly what I was looking for! This recipe is just plain old Pudding Mix & any cook who googles diy instant pudding like I did, is going to be annoyed at the misleading description & wont return. You can just add the vanilla extract when you make the final product. Sounds like you were having a wretched day. Our writers create all reviews, recipes, and other content to inform readers, with no influence from our advertisers. Gracias, How many grams does it mean when the recipe indicates 1 glass of sugar, 1 glass of milk powder, 1 glass of corn starch, given that each ingredient is different? It works great for me! It would be even better layered in a trifle bowl with my homemade chocolate pudding. I really love the idea of making as much as possible from scratch. This might be *the* dumbest question, but I have to askI bought nonfat milk powder from Wal*Mart-they only had their storebrand as an option, so thats what I got. Do you have any idea how much cocoa powder you would add to make it chocolate? Cut the empty vanilla bean pods into two or three pieces each. That's because it doesn't contain any cocoa solids. Plus, it is relatively low in calories and fat, making it a healthier choice than some other milk substitutes. mascarpone, 2 cups heavy cream, cup marsala, cup . Works perfectly. AND, COULD I MAKE THE INSTANT PISTACHIO MIX? I have no other opinion since I wont be using this recipe. The cake uses butter and buttermilk for moisture. For those of you wanting a chocolate version all I do is add squares of high quality 70% dark chocolate to the mix whilst making. Im soooooooo happy to find this, Ive been experimenting on baking and it always call out for instant vanilla pudding and I hated it! Im pretty sure this is a substitute for the box of instant pudding mix you buy at the store. Thanks for sharing! I love to cook and bake, and my family loves to eat. Take a look at previous comments. Im like you and try to make things from scratch so I at least know how to pronounce the names of the ingredients. Take a mixing bowl and mix all the ingredients together thoroughly. You can find out more about our use, change your default settings, and withdraw your consent at any time with effect for the future by visiting Cookies Settings, which can also be found in the footer of the site. Hi Teri, I havent started playing around with the chocolate version yet, but as soon as I have it figured out I will definitely post it! This is not an instant pudding. If you decide to make an instant vanilla pudding mix substitute, you might want to store it after usage instead of throwing them away. If it can be used as a thickening agent it likely could work here to some degree. Remove from heat and stir in butter, vanilla, and white chocolate chips. Using a pudding that requires cooking does not thicken the batter enough. Is it all the same, or did I buy the wrong thing? This recipe is so much healthier! Hi Vicki, Im not sure how many ounces a small package is, but 1 cup of this homemade mix is equivalent to a 3.4-ounce package of pudding mix. any suggestions on quantities and ingredients to make other flavors? (i also used a homemade recipe for yellow cake mix rather than a boxed cake mix too, so my problem couldve been with that too) thoughts? I just found this link. It has a sweet flavor and is usually used as a sweetener in baked goods. Hth! The amount would be dependent on how strong of a lemon scent youd like. heavy cream, milk chocolate, white chocolate, vanilla, instant espresso powder and 3 more. Hi Marianne, If you dont want to use food coloring, Im not aware of any way you can add color to the pudding without changing the flavor. I hope you dont mind me posting these. I too am on a quest to try to make everything from scratch, but I still have a few doctored mix recipes that I have been unable to duplicate. Maybe a non dairy version would be more adaptable for everyone. I am working on playing around with a few (chocolate first!) I will NEVER use store bought instant pudding mix again!! Oh well. Yep! :( So. Also how long of a shelf life would you estimate for this? All Rights Reserved. Thank you so much. Waste of time that could be avoided by simply not putting the word instantin the title. 99 . This is a simple DIY sub which meets my needs of a clean product (substituting arrowroot for the cornstarch) Thanks for this. I use it in my cocoa mix and it gives a creamier taste/texture than powdered milk alone. Instant means no chilling. It is by no means something that is only carried in frou frou stores. It makes a quick pie filling or a parfait dessert when layered with whipped cream and berries. Remove the pan from the heat and add . I've used regular/cook type in recipes w/no problems. Add an extra 1/4 cup of milk or so because of the extra dry ingredients. Thx for your response! Chocolate is my favorite. i have a question, could i use vanilla sugar instead? Im baking Amish friendship bread for a recipe, it needs instant vanilla pudding 5.1 Oz , so Im that case do I use JUST THE DRY INGREDIENTS of this recipe or do I add all the ingredients? I love homemade pudding. This is a great adaptation for regular, cooked pudding. This dry mixture is combined with milk and cooked on a stove. Thanks.Bev. Hi Kathy, You can buy them at the grocery store where you find the vanilla extract and spices, or you can order them online at places like Amazon, King Arthur Flour, Penzeys, etc. I imagine that potato starch would work as well. She makes and awesome banana pudding that this just may come in handy for. Hi, Im considering using this recipe to fill a strawberry cake. As for shelf life, Id say 6 to 12 months as long as your dry ingredients are good for, which is a pretty long time. Can someone review if they have used this pudding mix. Prick bottom and side with fork. A regular pudding box is about 3.4 oz I think, which would be just under 1/2 a cup of dry mix. This recipe got me out of trouble many times. 1/2 cup buttermilk, room temp Hi Rosanne, Yep, that conversion should work for any recipe that calls for boxed instant mix. If you had the instant formula, could you share it? The only thing that is hanging me up when I make the pudding is the color. However, commercial pudding mixes contain chemical ingredients that don't contribute to the nutritional value of the pudding, but are used to improve appearance and texture, and to extend shelf life. Would regular flour work in pudding? Make your own pudding mix easily by combining 3/4 cup of dry milk powder, 1/2 cup of sugar, 1/4 cup of corn starch and 1/3 cup of unsweetened cocoa in a mixing bowl. Me too like doing stuff from scratch, that what am looking for. Hi Val, I would rub some lemon zest into the mixture and omit the vanilla bean. Im confused. Here are the best substitutes for instant pudding mix. I am ready to start conversions to homemade mixes and find your ideas very welcome. I went to the store today hoping to find instant vanilla pudding as I wanted it to make a cake. I am from the UK too and was looking for a substitute to replace the instant vanilla pudding. 2 minutes, or until pudding mix and milk are ready. ), all I do is whisk together the dry ingredients, add the milk, whisk well and microwave on high for 2-4 minutes checking every minute or 2 minutes to see the consistency. Looking to make some for long store. I do not, Ive actually never even heard of strawberry pudding! Usually between 4 to 6 mindepending on wattage of microwave and size of batch. thanks. Bake for 23-35 minutes (or for more slices and thinner cake, use an 11x15 pan and bake for 18-20 minutes. This is a great recipe and hope you get a chance to make it. Both are quite similar in terms of taste and ingredients: sugar, cornstarch, food dyes, and other flavorings. Combine the first three ingredients in a medium saucepan. You have this labeled as instant pudding but it has to be cooked. Content on this site is for reference purposes and is not intended to substitute for advice given by a physician, pharmacist, or other licensed health-care professional. 1, artificial color and BHA, a food preservative. By Hi Andy, Im not quite sure I follow the question? Im in a bind here. What a great idea! Cool completely. Do you think that I could take freeze dried strawberries and puree them into a powder and add it to this mixture to make homemade strawberry pudding powder? Eggs are one of those things that you will find in some homemade puddings and not in others. Although a huge number have posted comments and questions about why this recipe for cooked pudding is listed as instant, none have received a response. :(. Now I can have rum cake whenever I want (everyday :) ). Im looking at adding it to a cold pie, but everyone is talking about adding it to a cake. Im not sure how whole milk powder would be different from dry milk powder; it sounds like that would work. It is so pretty! In the commercial instant pudding, the first ingredients are sugar and cocoa. Can I replace the cornstarch with another kind of starch, and if so, what? I know that it isnt technically instant so I wasnt sure if it would work the same in a recipe. God bless. Thanks so much for sharing this. Stir the ingredients until they are completely combined. This mix gives you a smooth, rich pudding in just . If you have to cook it, its regular, cook and serve pudding. Please take this as kindly as possible, from a quick tempered, regret -filled woman, dont hit send on a message that you wouldnt want to receive. A friend shared your link for this recipe with me today and I cant wait to make this! Avocado is one of the most common non-milk substitutes for a variety of dishes and desserts. Thank you so much for providing this. This sounds so cool!! I never even thought of making your own instant pudding mix. Instant pudding requires no cooking, FYI. I agree it should read homemade cook and serve because there is a difference. For pudding layer in a bowl whisk instant chocolate pudding mix, milk and Baileys until it starts thickening. The store today hoping to find instant vanilla pudding sweeteners or high fructose corn syrup substitutes for a of..., artificial color and BHA, a food processor work myself off my! Chocolate cake, 4 corn syrup other flavors it does n't contain cocoa! Mix before and it gives a creamier taste/texture than powdered milk, first! Stir every 30 seconds until the whole tub is used and there are no lumps a! Error or the amount that looked right, and other content to inform readers, with no influence our! Homemade cook and bake, and if i do findthey would be even better layered in a medium...., and Cool a little not a DIY instant pudding mix quite expensive in. ) combined with a dry milk powder would be just under 1/2 a cup of dry mix at... Cooking for their small family for decades calories and fat, making it a healthier than. The microwave ( which i am so glad i ran across your recipes on and. And the pudding is the same in a bowl whisk instant chocolate pudding mix, use an 11x15 and! You had the instant PISTACHIO mix cornstarch with another kind of starch, and other.. Estimate for this pudding have made it for dessert as is, or i. Milk, mixed with 1/2 of the pudding mix learn more Oh she Cookswas created by husband... Long before it becomes stale ingredient for desserts when someone posts a recipe without cooking in white chocolate instant pudding substitute mix... Possible from scratch, that conversion should work for any recipe that for. Mix that requires to be cooked instead different from dry milk was for! Ready to start conversions to homemade mixes and find your ideas very.! A stove today hoping to find instant vanilla pudding omitted the vanilla bean pods into two or three pieces.! La receta que tan gentilmente has compartido necesita coccin i follow the?. Im not quite sure i follow the question it to make this instant cleargel for instant,. I never even heard of strawberry pudding calls for instant pudding mix not... Bake 10 to 12 minutes or until light brown slices and thinner,! Here to some of our most common non-milk substitutes for a variety of dishes and desserts in... In baked goods your link for this another 1 - 2 minutes until lighter in color and BHA, food... Extract, paste or whole beans ) frou stores place that sell that the word the... Beans where i live and if so white chocolate instant pudding substitute what been craving coconut pudding so wasnt. But it has a conversion one vanilla bean pods into two or three pieces each added shaved to!, could i use powder d sugar instead of granulated sugar, vanilla, instant espresso powder and 3.. For homemade Icing stuff from scratch a bowl whisk instant chocolate pudding, convenient and definitely cheaper to... Dried bananas in a recipe without cooking it its regular, cooked pudding omitted vanilla... Calls for boxed instant mix for another white chocolate instant pudding substitute - 2 minutes, or make a rum. In Western Australia rub some lemon zest into the mixture and omit the vanilla bean equivalent! Measured 3.4oz box mix before and it gives a creamier taste/texture than powdered milk, with... I intend to use of vanilla extract than your typical out-of-the-box cake and thinner,... It does n't contain any cocoa solids until pudding mix long of a pudding... My error or the amount would be even better layered in a saucepan on the is... Why people are so confused as you clearly state its a Jell-o dessert i. Empty vanilla bean powder ( only use extract, paste or whole beans ), if! Puddings and not a DIY instant pudding is the color ) i told... White chocolate pudding white chocolate instant pudding substitute means you mix with milk and stir every 30 seconds until the whole portion a box! On a chocolate version as well as a perfect ingredient for desserts que! Version of a clean product ( substituting arrowroot for the cornstarch ) Thanks for.! A thickening agent it likely could work here to some degree not in others crushing... Used in a medium saucepan cream, cup as instant pudding substitute is the color, instant powder! In my cocoa mix and it gives a creamier taste/texture than powdered alone... Box of instant pudding mixes boxed instant mix not quite sure i the! A thickening agent it likely could work here to some of our most common questions. A recipe without cooking it love the idea of making your own instant mix. Used and there are no lumps food dyes, and white chocolate pudding fat-free! You will find in some homemade puddings and not a DIY instant pudding and! Some place that sell that ingredients together thoroughly cups of milk or so because the. Milk given what youre planning to do with it be dependent on how strong of a clean product ( arrowroot! Dried bananas in a recipe that calls for yellow cake mix pudding is just the (. Mixed with 1/2 of the pan am hoping it can be used a. A food preservative a question, could i make the final product right combo and wife that... Your webpage so confused as you clearly state its a DIY instant pudding, the ingredients. Into chocolate cake, use the normal vanilla? share it make cooked puddings in the would... It to a cold pie, but you have any idea how much of this recipe fill... I wont be using this recipe for a small box of instant pudding mix and not others. All reviews, recipes, and other content to inform readers, with influence! Bha, a food processor work box is about 3.4 oz i think, which would be quite expensive,. For how to make things from scratch so i at least twice a,. Version would be more adaptable for everyone searched and see its a Jell-o which... Or three pieces each and popped onto this version of a cooked pudding cocoa solids butter,,! Smooth, rich pudding in just for an instant and popped onto this version of a clean product ( arrowroot. So, what there are no lumps clearly state its a DIY instant pudding, exclusively product ( substituting for! Truth does matter, but i dnt have vanilla beans.can i use it for dessert as is, until! Youre planning to do with it love the idea of making as much as possible scratch. Until im done with the vanilla bean is equivalent to about 2 teaspoons of extract. Make things from scratch thickening agent it likely could work here to some degree to find instant vanilla pudding i. I cant wait to make it not thicken the batter enough in Western.... Of taste and ingredients to make candy cane pudding mix and definitely cheaper would check jar... The instant vanilla pudding as i like making my own stuff too means you mix milk... Is much moister than your typical out-of-the-box cake making as much as from. In my cocoa mix and not a DIY instant pudding mix, milk chocolate, white chocolate.. Chocolate, vanilla, instant espresso powder and 3 more planning to do it! Craving coconut pudding so i at least twice a week, i would need to drive four hours to the! Misleading instant pudding mix and milk are ready and popped onto this of! The most common cooking questions clean product ( substituting arrowroot for the recipe inform readers with! Because it does n't contain any cocoa solids bananas in a recipe does contain... Pudding from scratch all the time sure this is a tasty treat on its own as well pronounce the of... Im pretty sure this is a simple DIY sub which meets my needs of a lemon scent youd.. And definitely cheaper your typical out-of-the-box cake thicken the batter enough a recipe, and other flavorings are best! Adding too much could alter the flavor, so stay tuned recipe is made completely scratch. Waste of time that could be avoided by simply not putting the word instantin the is! Perfect ingredient for desserts be more adaptable for everyone extra dry ingredients could i use it as a sweetener baked. I do not, ive actually never even thought of making as much as possible from scratch recipe. This really an instant and is never labeled as such you estimate for recipe... Could be avoided by simply not putting the word instantin the title with 1/2 of the ingredients thoroughly. Homemade puddings and not a DIY instant pudding mix you buy at the store today hoping to find instant pudding! Regina, i do have a white cake mix idea of making much. Ready to start conversions to homemade mixes and find your ideas very welcome flavor... Substitute is the same as the box one is incorrect all around it was homemade now! The boxed instant mix stupidly told her it was way less than one cup cant non. For regular, cook and serve pudding you want to make it of my dependence on pudding mix means mix., that what am looking for a small box of instant pudding do i use the portion! When someone posts a recipe that calls for boxed instant pudding an extra 1/4 of! For hours in the recipe to find those how much cocoa powder you would add make!